Promising Young Woman is a Revenge Thriller that Puts the Power back in Pink


Review by Mimi Anagli
Developmentally Edited by Alexandra Hidalgo

Copy Edited and Posted by Iliana Cosme-Brooks

This review is part of a double feature on Promising Young Woman. For more check out this article on the controversial Variety review of the film.

Promising Young Woman (2020). 1h 53min. Directed by Emerald Fennell. Featuring Carey Mulligan, Bo Burnham, Laverne Cox, Alison Brie.

Cassie (Carey Mulligan) at coffee shop.

From a distance, Cassie Thomas’ life is filled with soft sunshine and pastel pleasantries. Her manicured nails and flowing sundresses hint at a sophisticated and polished lifestyle. One step into Cassie’s life quickly reveals that this hyper-feminine aesthetic is a distraction from the troubled woman she is. As a feminist revenge thriller, Emerald Fennell’s directorial debut Promising Young Woman is the cinematic embodiment of the statement, “Sweet as sugar, hard as ice. Hurt me once, I’ll kill you twice.” 

Cassie, played by Carey Mulligan, is the center of Fennell’s twisted yet accurate look into the repercussions of rape culture. Cassie is a medical school dropout dealing with the rape of her best friend Nina. Although the tragedy occurred years before we meet her, Cassie never truly moves on from the trauma and lets the grief consume her. She spends her days working at a coffee shop with her coworker and friend Gail (Laverne Cox) and her nights avenging Nina by luring in predators at bars and teaching them a lesson or two. Through Cox’s peppy and quick-witted performance, Gail brings out a playful and lighthearted side of Cassie that makes her premeditated dark side that much more startling. When someone from her past unexpectedly enters her life, Cassie’s devastating memories resurface, compelling her to take her avenging to new and self-destructive extremes. And just when you think Cassie is on the path to closure, she is faced with earth-shattering news that opens the old wound, acting as a catalyst for an unpredictable ending and an electrifying string rendition of Britney Spears’ “Toxic.”

The film’s masterfully calculated production design and cinematography places Cassie in a world of candy-colored deception. With bubblegum pink carpets, powder-blue curtains, and a suspicious number of floral patterns, Cassie’s surroundings create a false sense of purity and innocence. This contrast between the soft and delicate colors and Cassie’s broken-yet-iron-willed attitude towards life not only acts as a curveball, but it also puts the power back into a feminine aesthetic that is often associated with fragility and weakness. Cassie is undoubtedly a force to be reckoned with. By having her embrace a “girly” and “ladylike” style,  Promising Young Woman reclaims ways of presenting ourselves that have wrongly been perceived as meek or submissive, emphasizing that there is no definition of what a strong and bold woman looks like. 

Fennell’s informed and perceptive script combined with Mulligan’s phenomenal performance makes for a heart-wrenching story that touches on the silenced suffering that so many women go through. An aspect of sexual assault that doesn’t get enough attention in our media and cultural discussions is how psychologically damaging it is when victims are not believed. Fennell paints a very real picture of how assaults are pitted on the women. With key triggering phrases such as This could ruin a man’s life, Were you drinking?, and She was asking for it, Fennell gets to the core of how desensitized society has become to one of the most horrendous crimes a human can commit against another. 

Cassie lives with the weight of knowing that while this trauma destroyed Nina, her abusers live guilt-free, running with the narrative that she was asking for it, or that in some sadistic way she deserved it. No one truly understands what that weight feels like until they’ve experienced it themselves, which is why Cassie is determined to torment the abusers and bystanders to the point where they feel the pain she feels. Unfortunately, Cassie is searching for justice in a situation where it doesn’t exist, because nothing she does will bring Nina back to her. Although the past cannot be undone, Cassie knows that more often than not, predators are repeat offenders. As long as she can stop serial perpetrators from hurting other women, there is reason for her to continue. Another driving force for her actions is the guilt that keeps her up at night. As the heart-shaped friendship necklace that Cassie wears suggests, Nina was her other half. With a relationship that predates every milestone in their lives, Cassie and Nina were inseparable, and Cassie feels guilty for not being there the time Nina needed her the most. This combination of vengeance and guilt is why she is willing to go to any lengths in her mission for revenge. There is a stark moment where a character whose life she is threatening to ruin tells her to think about what she’s doing. Cassie responds, “I cannot begin to tell you how much I’ve thought about this.” Those unsettling words reflect how this kind of suffering can consume a person’s every thought, eating away at their grasp on a healthy mental state.

Carey Mulligan’s ability to convey two strikingly different tones in a single narrative brings a unique depth to the film. Her performance is an exemplary look at what multifaceted women characters look like in the thriller genre. With the incorporation of signifiers of traumatic stress such as coping rituals (Cassie putting a scrunchie around her hand every time she opens her journal) and stunted emotional growth (her having no desire to move out of her parents’ home),  Promising Young Woman shows careful consideration for a heavy topic while offering an entertaining and empowering story in the wake of the #metoo movement and a new age of accountability and consent education. Earning four Golden Globe nominations,  Promising Young Woman is rightfully taking this year’s award season by storm, opening the door for more bold and daring stories told by women.

Currently, you can watch Promising Young Woman online by buying it through platforms like YouTube, Google Play, Apple TV, and Amazon Prime Video. Keep up with Emerald Fennell and her work by checking out her IMDB and Twitter pages. Connect with Mimi Anagli through her profile.